Book Review – Moments that could have changed football forever. What if? by Peter Prickett & Peter Thornton

At the end of ninety minutes across the world fans will invariably ask, “What If?” As fans, we’ve all done it. And it doesn’t just confine itself to the action on the pitch. Many will ask the same question, whether about managerial appointments, player transfers than never materialised, or indeed any situation which had a bearing on their beloved team.

Content wise, the book contains 28 What If scenarios and has the authors justifying their selections on the following basis: “We tended to go for moments that, when projected further, had real knock-on effects that would have changed the course of football history.”

The various scenarios selected for the book will no doubt be up for debate as every fan will have their own which would have changed the history of their club. Readers will also have their own opinions on the outcomes the authors deliver, however, as Prickett and Thornton say in the books Introduction,If you have disagreed with them then it means our writing has achieved its goal”.

Each chapter is essentially in two parts, the first is a factual summary in respect of the What If question, with the second part, the authors taking the reader through their view of how a situation could play out. What is just as important as to the ‘new’ outcome that Prickett and Thornton detail, are the things that never do come to pass, since the timeline and those in it now go down a different path – football v science fiction.

There is a good mix of situations that the authors come up with and includes three chapters which pit some notable teams down the years against each other, with Brazil 1970 v Spain 2008-2012, Hungary 1954 v Holland 1974 and Real Madrid Galacticos 1960 v Real Madrid Galacticos 2002. Prickett and Thornton both have a coaching background and they use this to good effect in detailing how the contrasting styles, eras and players might have matched up.

Elsewhere this reader has three favourites from the book, The first is the What If an African Team Win the World Cup, which sees Nigeria lift the trophy in 1994 with a potentially seismic impact on the French national team. The second is What If Brian Clough Had Managed England, with the mercurial manager taking over in 1977 after Don Revie’s resignation and how this would have shaped England’s fate on the European and World stage. Lastly, What If Technology Took Over From the Referee, which is a thought provoking, yet chilling view of how the game could change as technology and social media could take and split the beautiful game. A great way to end the book.

Overall an intriguing read which quite simply takes football fantasy to its extreme with some interesting conclusions.

(Publisher: Pitch Publishing Ltd. June 2023. Hardcover: 320 pages)

 

Buy the book here: What if?

Category: Reviews | LEAVE A COMMENT

2022 William Hill Sports Book of the Year Shortlist

Two football titles have made this year’s Shortlist, with Beryl by Jeremy Wilson looking at the life of cycling champions Beryl Burton, God is Dead by Andy McGrath capturing the chaotic life of cyclist Frank Vandenbroucke and the story of athlete Anyika Onuora, My Hidden Race making up the five book Shortlist.

Here’s a look at the two football titles.

Expected Goals: The Story of how Data Conquered Football and Changed the Game Forever by Rory Smith

Football has always measured success by what you win, but only in the last twenty years have clubs started to think about how you win. Data has now suffused almost every aspect of how football is played, coached, scouted and consumed. But it’s not the algorithms or new metrics that have made this change, it’s the people behind them.

This is the story of modern football’s great data revolution and the group of curious, entrepreneurial personalities who zealously believed in its potential to transform the game. Central to this cast is Chris Anderson, an academic with no experience in football, who saw data as an opportunity to fundamentally change a sport that did not think it could be changed. His aim: to infiltrate the strange, insular world of professional football by establishing a club whose entire DNA could be built around data.

Expected Goals charts his remarkable journey into the heart of the modern game and reveals how clubs across the world, from Liverpool to Leipzig and Brentford to Bayern Munich, began to see how data could help them unearth new players, define radical tactics and plot their path to glory.

(Publisher: Mudlark. September 2022. Hardcover: 304 pages)

Buy the book here: Expected Goals

Be Good, Love Brian: Growing Up with Brian Clough by Craig Bromfield

Craig Bromfield was just 13 years old when Brian Clough, on a whim, took him and his older brother Aaron in.

They came from Southwick, a depressed area of Sunderland, where they lived with their abusive stepfather, and from where they longed to escape. After initially meeting Clough while out begging for money, Clough later invited the brothers to stay at his house. From there a relationship formed which would see Craig living with the Cloughs for nine years, where he was a first-hand witness to the many aspects of Clough’s character – his gruffness, his humour, his big-heartedness.

This is a beautiful, inspirational story, which has never before been told, about Clough’s gentleness and capacity for generosity. Discover a very different side to this iconic man, one away from the cameras and the football, which shows him for the person he really was.

(Publisher: Mudlark. November 2021 Hardcover: 336 pages)

Buy the book here: Be Good, Love Brian

Category: General | LEAVE A COMMENT

2022 William Hill Sports Book of the Year Longlist

The longlist for the 34th William Hill Sports Book of the Year Award has been revealed. A record 158 books were entered into this year’s Award, featuring a diverse mix of authors from across a wide range of sports including, tennis, football, athletics, golf, rugby and cycling.

Following a rigorous judging process from a panel including The Athletics’ Nancy Frostick, sports presenter Matt Williams and William Hill’s Neil Foggin, 15 authors have been selected for this year’s longlist.

The 15-book longlist features an array of topics including hard-hitting autobiographies and heart-breaking memories, along with harrowing accounts of racism and sexism in sport and never-been-heard before encounters of some of the most compelling figures within the sporting industry.

With the Lionesses winning the UEFA Women’s EURO 2022 in July and the FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 taking place at the end of the year, it’s no surprise that topics around football dominates this year’s longlist, with eight books making the list. Cycling provides three titles, with athletics, golf, rugby union and tennis represented each with a single title.

Three female authors made the cut with retired track and field athlete Anyika Onuora, The Guardian’s football writer Suzanne Wrack, and former Irish international footballer Clare Shine are in the running for the Award. The story of female athlete Beryl Burton, who dominated the world of cycling, also features in the longlist.

Former sports stars, and first-time authors, Patrice Evra and Steve Thompson have also made the list for the Award which has a £30,000 cash prize for the winner.

The William Hill Sports Book of the Year 2022 Longlist:

Be Good, Love Brian: Growing Up with Brian Clough by Craig Bromfield (Football)

The Master: The Brilliant Career of Roger Federer by Christopher Clarey (Tennis)

1999: Manchester United, the Treble and All That by Matt Dickinson (Football)

Le Fric: Family, Power and Money: The Business of the Tour de France by Alex Duff (Cycling)

I Love This Game by Patrice Evra (Football)

England Football: The Biography: 1872-2022 by Paul Hayward (Football)

God is Dead: The Rise and Fall of Frank Vandenbroucke, Cycling’s Great Wasted Talent by Andy McGrath (Cycling)

My Hidden Race by Anyika Onuora (Athletics)

Scoring Goals in the Dark by Clare Shine with Gareth Maher (Football)

Phil: The Rip-Roaring (and Unauthorised) Biography of Golf’s Most Colourful Superstar by Alan Shipnuck (Golf)

Expected Goals: The Story of how Data Conquered Football and Changed the Game Forever by Rory Smith (Football)

Unforgettable: Rugby, Dementia and the Fight of My Life by Steve Thompson (Rugby Union)

Beryl: In Search of Britain’s Greatest Athlete, Beryl Burton by Jeremy Wilson (Cycling)

Two Brothers: The Life and Times of Bobby and Jackie Charlton by Jonathan Wilson (Football)

A Woman’s Game: The Rise, Fall and Rise Again of Women’s Football by Suzanne Wrack (Football)

Category: General | LEAVE A COMMENT

Book Review – Regrets of a Football Maverick: The Terry Curran Autobiography by Terry Curran with John Brindley

Thanks to the internet, information about players from the past are available after a quick search. For instance Sheffield Wednesday fans of a certain vintage looking for Terry Curran (voted The Owls all-time Cult Hero in a poll run by the BBC), on Wikipedia will find his entry tells us that his professional playing career lasted from 1973 through to 1986, taking in sixteen clubs (including loans) here in England, as well as brief sojourns in Sweden and Greece. Whilst this is useful to an extent in a factual sense, these figures do nothing to provide a detailed picture of the man and his career, and instead raises questions such as why Curran played for so many Clubs, how did he come to play for both Sheffield teams, and what was his relationship with some of the big management names at the time, such as Brian Clough, Jack Charlton, Tommy Docherty and Howard Kendall.

These questions and more are answered in Curran’s 2012 autobiography, Regrets of a Football Maverick. The title itself is telling, with the immediate suggestion to readers that this look back on his career and life has made Curran reflect and so question some of the things he did, given that during his playing career he was a forthright and confident individual, not afraid to say his piece.

One thing to say straight away is that this is a tale from the 1970s and 80s when football and indeed society was very different to that today and as the dustjacket warns (slightly tongue-in-cheek), “Terry Curran’s story may offend the politically correct!”.

In terms of the content of the book, it follows a fairly traditional timeline, with the opening chapter dedicated to Curran’s childhood growing up in Kinsley, a village in West Yorkshire, about eight miles southeast of Wakefield. Immediately within this opening to the book, readers are provided with an insight into an event that was to impact Curran significantly. When he was just eight years old, his parents split with his mother leaving the family home. As Curran writes in the book, “emotionally I was never the same kid…Dad was heart-broken and that had a big influence on me.” This resulted in him stating that, he was “never going to allow any female to get close enough to cause me the same upset. That lack of trust stayed with me for a lot of my adult life” and goes some way to explaining why he was a self-confessed womaniser during his playing career.

The opening chapter also details how Curran came to support Sheffield Wednesday, after being hooked despite The Owls giving up a two-goal lead against Everton in the 1966 FA Cup Final. Readers also get to read about Curran’s youth career playing representative football for the South Kirby Boys District team and for Kinsley Boys which led to offers from league clubs Halifax Town and Doncaster Rovers. Curran opted for Donny given its close proximity to home and his talent was rewarded when manager Maurice Setters offered him a professional contract.

Curran made his debut for Rovers on Saturday 29 September 1973 away at Gillingham, with Doncaster losing 5-1, with a highlight during that season, playing against Liverpool in the FA Cup Third Round replay (the Merseysiders went on to lift the trophy). He was making a name for himself in more ways than one, with the Club mistakenly detailing Curran to the press as ‘Terry’ despite him being christened ‘Edward.’ Clubs were expressing interest in the promising young winger with then First Division clubs, Leeds United, Everton and Sheffield United all apparently keen to sign him. However, it was to be beside the River Trent that Curran opted for and a move to Nottingham Forest and manager Brian Clough in August 1975, then languishing in the Second Division. At the time Curran, saw it as, “a chance to play for one of the game’s greatest managers.”

Programme: Fulham v Nottingham Forest 1976/77

Curran devotes a whole chapter to his time at Forest, with his admiration for Clough and his unique style of management evident. Take Curran’s introduction to the rest of the Reds squad, with Clough telling Martin O’Neill, “I’d like to introduce you to the young man who will be taking your place on Saturday.” Curran’s second season at Forest was the 1976/77 campaign, which opened with a fixture at Craven Cottage to play Fulham. The game ended 2-2 with Curran scoring what he considers to be his best ever goal – “picking the ball up on the halfway line, I beat four defenders before lobbing the ball high into the net high beyond goalkeeper Richard Teale.” George Best (who was a football hero for Curran) was in the crowd that day having signed for the SW6 Club and said, “I was really impressed. He (Curran) is a very good player.” That season was to see Forest gain promotion to the top flight, but Curran was to miss a significant part of it with a cruciate ligament injury suffered in October 1976. Having worked his way back into the side in March, the relationship at Forest began to break down with Curran dropped from the team in the run-in and little playing time at the start of the 1977/78 season as the Club took the First Division by storm to finish the campaign as Champions. By the time the title was being lifted at the City Ground, Curran was at Derby County under the watch of Tommy Docherty.

As Forest went onto be European Champions twice and win numerous other domestic trophies under Clough and Taylor it was a case of what have been for Curran. If he had got his head down and waited and remained injury-free, who is to say he might have got a regular place in the side. As Curran reflects, “If only I could have put an older head on my young shoulders. I turned my back on one of the most successful sides of that generation – any generation.”

Curran’s stay at the Baseball Ground was a brief one with 26 appearances and two goals for The Rams and acknowledged, “I didn’t play as consistently well as I know I could have.” Curran’s main other observation from his time at Deby was that “I don’t think Tommy (Docherty) adjusted to the culture shock of…the real world at Derby after being a constant source of national attention at Old Trafford.” So as the 1978/79 campaign started, Curran swapped the East Midlands for Hampshire at Lawrie McMenemy’s Southampton in what was to prove another one season stay.

Programme 1978-79 League Cup Final

It was both a positive and negative experience. On the one-hand it saw Curran make his one and only appearance in a Final at Wembley, as the Saints lost to Forest 3-2, and strike up a great friendship with 1966 World Cup winner, Alan Ball, but on the other, witnessed a difficult relationship with the Southampton boss. Curran’s criticism was centred on McMenemy’s inability to motivate the dressing room and over-reliance on the senior players within the squad which was detrimental to the younger Saint talent. It was also at Southampton that Curran first encountered cortisone injections to deal with pain in his right leg. Like many other players at the time, they were in common use, and it was only years later that the consequences for ex-players has come to light with the overuse of the treatment.

Curran’s beginning of the end at The Dell comes about in strange circumstances. With Southampton having just beaten Leeds United in the League Cup Semi-Final 2nd Leg, and whilst out celebrating, Curran is ‘approached’ by Jack Charlton who was then manager of Sheffield Wednesday to drop down two divisions to play at Hillsborough. Despite McMenemy’s plans to make some money out of a deal to send Curran to play football in the United States, in March 1979 The Owls signed Curran.

Programme: The Boxing Day Massacre 1979/80

Given that the blue and white of Wednesday had run through Curran’s veins since he was a young boy perhaps it is no shock that his time in S6 was the happiest of his career. During his stint at the Club he helped them to promotion from the Third Division in the 1979/80 campaign, finishing with 24 league goals and claiming the Divisional Golden Boot Award. One game stands out from that season, a performance that went a long way to giving Curran his Cult-hero status at Hillsborough – the ‘Boxing Day Massacre’ as he destroyed Sheffield United 4-0 in front of a third-tier record gate of 49,309. In the following season Wednesday looked good going into the final part of the campaign for a real tilt at promotion to the top flight, but fell away, with Curran critical of Jack Charlton’s lack of spending in the transfer market. Their relationship continued to be fractious with an infamous scrap between them in the Club gym a sign of the different ways the men view how the game should be played. It came to a head when Curran’s three year deal at Wednesday ended, with the management refusing to meet the new contract demands. Out of the blue, Wednesday’s cross-city rivals Sheffield United came in for Curran, who admits that for the first time in his career he moved for the money.

It proved to be a short and pretty unhappy stay at Bramall Lane, with Curran unimpressed by the coaching and training at the Club and both sets of fans in Sheffield less than enamoured with the maverick winger. Salvation came with a loan spell to First Division Everton during the 1982/83 season. This was made permanent in the following campaign, but once again Curran’s luck was out, picking up an injury in September 1983 that kept him out of the game until April 1984. Having worked his way back to fitness and playing in the FA Cup Semi-Final win over Southampton, the Twin Towers beckoned for Curran. However, three weeks before the Final, he suffered a hamstring injury and with it went any chance of an appearance in an FA Cup Final. Everton were becoming a force and in 1984/85 went onto to become First Division winners. Curran played enough games to earn a medal, but once again his emotional nature landed him in serious trouble and an exit from Goodison Park.

With injuries ahead of a European Cup Winners Cup Semi-Final First Leg in Munich, Curran believed his chances of starting the game were good but wanted this confirmed in training. Howard Kendall said he wouldn’t make a decision until shortly before kick-off, so Curran decided that he wasn’t prepared to go to the airport and travel with the squad. He was never selected in the starting line-up or on the bench again. As Curran reflects, “a crazy decision had once again sealed my exit from a great football club, and I was the obvious loser.” Left with no real option, Curran asked for a free transfer and for the 1985/86 season found himself back in Yorkshire at Huddersfield Town.

This move was effectively the beginning of the end of Curran’s career, with injuries taking a toll on his ability to play week-in, week-out. Despite that he managed seven goals in just over thirty appearances for The Terriers. Retirement though beckoned and over the next few years (1986 – 1989) Curran played for seven clubs (Panionios [Greece], Hull City, Sunderland, Grantham Town, Grimsby Town, Chesterfield and Goole Town) but only making a handful of appearances for each. Whilst at Goole he also managed the team, with fate once again proving unkind to Curran, as the financial position of the Club collapsed leading to the eventual demise of Goole Town. He then tried his hand with Mossley in 1992/93, but it proved to another difficult and brief spell in the dug-out with seven defeats in seven games and inevitably the sack.

At that point Curran walked away from football and went into business. Once again like his football career, he seems to have had more than his fair share of back luck, with a lucrative land sale becoming complicated and ending in a protracted legal case. Back in 2012 when the book was written, Curran was living a more settled life with partner Lynne and two sons, Tom and Jock and had done his coaching badges and was working at the Doncaster Rovers Centre Excellence.

For all the tales of on and off-field shenanigans, fall-outs, goals and girls, there is a serious side to this book. And Curran talks with honesty and openness about the mistakes he made in his playing career and in his personal life, and the implications of his series of injuries and his tempestuous and at times impetuous nature. The reality is that it takes courage and strength to admit when we are wrong and even more to put it into print and make it public.

Therefore the final word should go to Curran himself. “I was supposed to be the rebel who played as if tomorrow didn’t exist. The truth was…that I underachieved. I can’t help but wonder what would have happened had I not suffered that terrible injury at Forest and if I’d stayed injury-free when I got my last big chance in the game at Everton. But mostly I got it wrong myself. I picked too many arguments, ruffled too many feathers and took too many wrong turnings.”

 

(Publisher: Vertical Editions. October 2012. Hardcover: 272 pages)

 

Buy the book here: Terry Curran – Regrets of a Football Maverick

Category: Reviews | LEAVE A COMMENT

BLOODY SOUTHERNERS – CLOUGH AND TAYLOR’S BRIGHTON & HOVE ODYSSEY by Spencer Vignes

In 1973, Brian Clough and Peter Taylor stunned the football world by taking charge of Brighton & Hove Albion, a sleepy backwater club that had rarely done anything in its 72-year existence to trouble the headline writers. The move made no sense. Clough was managerial gold dust, having led Derby County to the Football League title and the semi-finals of the European Cup. He and his sidekick Peter Taylor could have gone anywhere. Instead they chose Brighton, sixth bottom of the old Third Division.

Featuring never-before-told stories from the players who were there, Bloody Southerners lifts the lid for the first time on what remains the strangest managerial appointment in post-war English football, one that would push Clough and Taylor’s friendship and close working relationship to breaking point.

Read our review here: Book Review: Bloody Southerners – Clough and Taylor’s (footballbookreviews.com)

(Publisher: Biteback Publishing. October 2018. Paperback: 320 pages)

THE DAMNED UTD by David Peace

In 1974 the brilliant and controversial Brian Clough made perhaps his most eccentric decision: he accepted the position of Leeds United manager. A successor to Don Revie, his bitter adversary, Clough was to last just 44 days.

In one of the most acclaimed British novels of recent years – subsequently made into a film starring Michael Sheen – David Peace takes us into the mind and thoughts of Ol’ Big ‘Ead himself and brings vividly to life one of football’s most complex and fascinating characters.

(Publisher: Faber & Faber. Main edition April 2007. Paperback: 368 pages)

Book Review – The Lions’ King by Bryan King

During the 1960s, ‘70s and ‘80s England was particularly blessed with an array of goalkeeping talent, from the World Cup winning Gordon Banks, through to Ray Clemence and Peter Shilton. However, there was a dearth of other talented players who could also have pulled on (and did in some cases) the Three Lions shirt during that time, with the likes of Peter Bonetti, Joe Corrigan, Jim Montgomery, Phil Parkes, Jimmy Rimmer, Alex Stepney and Gordon West all highly regarded First Division ‘keepers. Given that, it is all the more remarkable that Bryan King, who whilst playing his trade at Second Division Millwall, also forced his way into the England set-up during the early 1970s.

The Lions’ King tells the story of Bryan King, who after starting his career at Chelmsford City in 1964, signed professionally for Millwall three years later. Down at Cold Blow Lane, he made a record number of appearances for a ‘keeper, which would later see him become a member of the Millwall Hall of Fame. King then moved to First Division Coventry City in 1975, but after only one season in the top-flight, his career was cruelly ended by injury.

However, King had wisely started his FA Coaching badges during his playing days, so that he was able to take up managing and coaching positions once his career was cut short and it enabled him enjoy stints in Norway with FK Jerv, Harstad, Tynset, Rendalen, Kongsberg, and Falkenberg in Sweden. He later stayed in the game showing his versatility and talent in becoming a journalist for a Norwegian sports paper, working as an agent and in more recent years as a scout for clubs such as Aston Villa, Everton and Tottenham Hotspur.

King’s extensive involvement in the game is told in three main sections, titled Player, Manager and Saved Till Last and to be honest it is a real page-turner. Stylistically it is very conversational, often humorous, and as a reader I felt like I was sat down with King in a bar, sharing the anecdotes and stories over a few pints. There are gems of tales littered throughout the book, whether it is acting as a ball boy at Wembley and getting to meet his boyhood goalkeeping heroes, Lev Yashin and Gordon Banks, detailing the antics of the Millwall dressing rooms or mixing with the likes of Brian Clough and Sven-Goran Eriksson.

This is not to say serious issues aren’t addressed, such as dementia in players, however, they are only dealt with in the briefest of terms, and with King’s extensive time and experience in the game and in various roles, it would have been interesting if he had expanded on those topics.

As well as charting King’s undoubtedly varied and interesting time in the game, it is a book about a very different time in football, a game much more rough around the edges, but no worse off for being so. And on that basis it is a book that will appeal to anybody wanting an insight into football as it was.

 

(Little Hell Books. November 2020. Hardback 320 pages)

 

Category: Reviews | LEAVE A COMMENT

Top Ten Football Books: Stuart Kane

Stuart Kane is a novelist, researcher, and primary school teacher who was born in Birmingham. He had trials at Aston Villa as a youngster and was on the books at Walsall FC but wasn’t offered YTS forms. He then turned his focus to rugby where he played rugby league for Ireland Students in the mid-nineties.

The soon to be released Man Friday: the second half, tells the story of cult football legend, Robin Friday, and his time at Reading and Cardiff City and kicks on from where his first football novel, Man Friday: the first half, finished. His academic interview with the author, Kevin Barry, appears in Conversations with Biographical Novelists: Truthful Fictions across the Globe and was published by Bloomsbury in 2019.

Stuart’s passion for football and biographical fiction combined to create Man Friday (The Life and Times of Robin Friday). ‘I wanted to bring Robin Friday back to life and tell his story more authentically. It had to be told from Robin’s point of view, not wanting to stray too far from the facts, and to try and find out what really happened to him during his life. He was an exceptionally complex character, and my books stay true to his spirit and character.’

Stuart was a Liverpool supporter as a lad citing his love of Ian Rush’s goalscoring exploits, then John Barnes’ sheer magic as the main reasons for this. A supporting nomad he’d often travel to watch local league sides such as Wolves, Birmingham City, Villa, Walsall, and non-league sides Sutton Coldfield Town and Solihull Moors. He then decided to support Aston Villa and has been following them ever since, which he describes as a rollercoaster. Stuart’s top ten football books, in no particular order, are:

The Miracle of Castel di Sangro by Joe McGinniss (1999)

Well, we might as well start with a bit of controversy, so here’s the story of Castel di Sangro. The Italian minnows, who for a brief time, punched above their weight in Serie B. The author, Joe McGinniss, returned his one-million-dollar advance after refusing to write the OJ Simpson trial book. He called the OJ trial “an utter farce”. McGinniss fell in love with the beautiful game during the 1994 World Cup in the US. He said that he just wanted to be a sportswriter focussing on European football. McGinniss described this as therapy; it also helped him feel twenty years younger. McGinniss threw himself into Italian life, picking up the language, becoming friends with the players, fans, and coaches. The book is enthralling, and the drama that unfolds couldn’t be scripted. Fact is always stranger than fiction – to spin a cliché. I won’t give too much away here, but let’s just say McGinniss may well have been left to reflect on his OJ Simpson trial comments. It’s a dynamite book, and McGinniss’ passion shines through. He tries to stay objective but soon gets pulled into club politics and can’t stop himself from getting involved. At one point he falls out with the manager over the team selection, but that’s a relatively minor matter when compared to what later unfolds. You are pulled into this book by McGinniss’ superb writing, and he takes you on one hell of a ride.

The Blinder by Barry Hines (1966)

This was Barry Hines’ first novel, and it tells the story of Lenny Hawk, a brilliant young footballer. He is tough, talented, and trying to make a name for himself. Hawk is also a good college student and has an interest in his boss’ daughter, but he’s also got enemies who play for higher stakes. It’s a rich debut novel. Hines himself was both a good student and a tasty footballer. The author represented England Schoolboys, played for Barnsley’s reserves, and later, Loughborough University, Crawley Town, and Stocksbridge Works. We might assume then that there’s a lot of authentic experience behind the writing. The central character is a working-class lad with brains, who has his flaws. The dialogue is solid in this book, and that’s why I love it; it’s inspiring, and there is a rawness to it, but it’s all the richer for that. This is an often-overlooked classic, as Hines is more widely known for his novel, A Kestrel for a Knave (1968) – which became the classic film, KesKestrel for a Knave contains, in my opinion, the most singularly perfect portrayal of a game of football on a school playing field in the English language. If you can get hold of an old copy of Blinder, I’d recommend it.

Only a Game? by Eamon Dunphy (1976) 

Eamon Dunphy, a marmite pundit, often mocked in his home country. He was a product of the excellent Stella Maris FC youth system. Then as a teenager, he moved to Manchester United but didn’t break through into the first team due to this being a golden age for United in terms of playing staff. Still, he went on to play for the Republic of Ireland and carved out a decent football career for himself. Towards the end of his time in the game, he started writing for a local paper in Reading while turning out for Reading FC. At Reading, he was drinking partner, friend, and guide to the one and only Robin Friday. Only a Game? tells the story of the 1973-74 season at Millwall through Dunphy’s personal diary – a form which has inspired many a football writer since. It records the events from the dressing-room and the struggles of being a professional footballer. Dunphy’s voice is clear, concise, and he captures the golden moments and failures with precision but more importantly, with emotion. This is a must-read if you have an interest in football books.

I Believe in Miracles: The Remarkable Story of Brian Clough’s European Cup-winning Team by Daniel Taylor and Jonny Owen (2015)

This book is pure and simple magic. It weaves the story of Ol’ Big’ Ead, or the one and only Brian Clough, or God as he’s known in some circles. The foreword is penned by José Mourinho, who freely admits his admiration and fondness for Clough. The book begins in January 1975 with Nottingham Forest sitting in thirteenth place in the old Second Division. They scrape promotion to the First Division, and that’s where the partnership of Clough and Taylor is rekindled. The personal reflections from the players help us understand how they were managed by Clough, and both his flaws and genius are on show for the reader. It is about the success of the team as a whole, as well as the Clough/Taylor partnership, and shows what can happen when all the parts pull together in the same direction. Nottingham Forest was a team full of characters: John Robertson, Martin O’Neill, John McGovern, Kenny Burns etc. The book allows these unique characters to tell their own stories and how they fared when pitted against the mighty Clough. Forest’s footballing feat will never be surpassed, or even equalled. Read the book, watch the accompanying DVD, laugh, cry, and go on this beautiful footballing joy ride.

The Damned Utd by David Peace (2006) 

The book that inspired me to pen Man Friday. David Peace read all the different books that had been written about the Leeds United team from the 1970s. Many of the books were by the Leeds’ players or had been ghost-written for them. Peace found that there were many contradictions. This is of course, natural as people remember events differently, or simply wrongly. Peace’s vision was of a man filled with frustration and regret about his own playing career. Regrets about leaving Derby County, further bitterness at having joined Brighton & Hove Albion. A man who felt that he should have been the England manager. Then Clough, of course, had the feeling that people were conspiring against him at Leeds United. It’s a dark book in places, but there’s not too much doubt that Clough regretted taking on the role at Leeds. It was a bizarre move for Clough, who had constantly spoken out against Leeds United’s tough tactics. He’d also called out their master, Don Revie, on several occasions. It was only ever going to go one way. Peace’s use of the first and second person flows like a brook, and this is a masterclass in writing about football. The best football novel ever written.

Red or Dead by David Peace (2013)

Peace’s epic biographical novel built around the footballing great, Bill Shankly. There are many levels to this book. It can be seen to represent the demise of the British working class, socialism and the trade unions, as well as being the antithesis of the footballing values of yesteryear versus modern-day football. We follow Shankly’s journey as he seeks to build Liverpool into a dominant force in domestic and European football. To get the voice of Shankly, Peace listened to the recordings of Shankly’s voice over, and over again. Peace borrowed the tapes from retired journalist John Roberts, what he noticed was Shankly’s use of repetitions, and he would go on to use these in the novel. The book’s themes can, at times, dominate proceedings, at the expense of the story. Still, it is a journey and builds up piece by piece as Shankly did with his mighty Liverpool.

Shankly: My Story with John Roberts (1976) 

This book was written after Bill Shankly had left Liverpool and caused a lot of controversy at the time. Shankly spoke openly about his treatment by Liverpool, after his shock resignation in the summer of 1974. This book was ghost-written by John Roberts, a former journalist. Shankly said this book was ninety-nine per cent about people and one per cent criticism, but he said people had chosen to focus on that one per cent. Shankly claimed that he had just stated the facts. You can’t help but admire Shankly for what he did for that football club and the people of Liverpool. There are some great tales in this book, and we see humour, anger, frustration, but we see Shankly as he wanted to be seen and remembered. The book is testament to the foundations upon which Liverpool Football Club is built and which Jurgen Klopp continues to build on to this day. Shankly was a man for all seasons, but more importantly, he made the people happy.

El Diego: the autobiography of the world’s greatest footballer with Marcelo Mora Y Araujo (2005)  

In this autobiography, we follow Diego Armando Maradona, or Maradona as he is known across the globe. To a whole nation, he is ‘El Pibe de Oro’ (The Golden Boy). This is Maradona in his own words. I read this book when it first came out, as, like most of us, I was fascinated by this footballing legend. A character who is capable of creating delight and frustration in equal amounts, and sometimes both in a single moment. As you’d expect Maradona shoots from the hip and doesn’t hold back. We relive some of Maradona’s greatest moments. We’re left feeling that he could’ve achieved even more as a player, were it not for his extra-curricular activities. Love or hate Maradona, he has that charm and charisma that carries you along and draws you to him. He was the greatest footballer that there’s ever been in my opinion. Maradona played at a time when defenders could still crush you with leg-breaking menace. He danced amongst defenders, fought with them, and beat them all. All of this while battling with his own demons and addictions. This book encapsulates Maradona’s character and spirit. If you’ve seen Asif Kapadia’s documentary Diego Maradona, you’ll enjoy this book, and if you’ve not seen that documentary, then please do.

Angels with Dirty Faces: The Footballing History of Argentina by Jonathan Wilson (2016) 

I have a love of Argentinian football and its history, from the national jersey to the greats of Batistuta, Di Stéfano, Kempes, Maradona, Messi etc. Wilson’s book delves deeply into the game but also talks about the socio-political and economic elements that have influenced Argentina and explores how these have impacted upon its football. Football runs through the blood of every Argentinian and as a writer of great detail, that can only come about through significant research, knowledge, and passion. Wilson tells us everything we need to know about football in this fascinating country. He doesn’t shy away from looking at the corruption that has plagued Argentinian football either – World Cup 1978 for a start. In fact, Wilson covers one of my favourite football mavericks the late, Tomás Felipe Carlovich. A player, arguably good enough to play for the national side but who decided to play for his local teams of Rosario and Central Córdoba instead. A home bird and footballing genius famous for his ‘double nutmeg’. José Pekerman chose Carlovich as the best central midfielder he’d ever seen. Maradona said Carlovich was better than him. Wilson’s book is a search for the soul of Argentinian football, and he doesn’t disappoint. Knowing how much effort and groundwork it takes to produce something this epic, I can only take my hat off to Jonathan Wilson and say thank you. An incredible book that is a must-read for those fascinated with Argentina, and it’s first love, football.

Iron Towns by Anthony Cartwright (2016)

Anthony Cartwright takes on the difficult feat of producing a novel that is about football, but which is not about any known player or team. What Cartwright has crafted is a unique novel which shines a light on struggling football clubs in forgotten towns and the impact of industrial progress and the resulting fallout when dreams fall away. It follows Liam Corwen, journeyman defender, who returns back to his hometown club, after divorce, and a brief appearance in the Finnish league. Corwen, it tells us once played for England as a substitute, but according to everyone he never touched the ball. He knows that he did, in fact, touch it very lightly, with a header which sent the ball away from his opponents. This is a beautiful and subtle book which is layered and combines the sentimentality of football with a deeper exploration of both the changing face of the game and also the world in which the game exists. It is also about the function of clubs within their community and their importance, something which is now perhaps more prudent than ever.

 

Book Review: Bloody Southerners – Clough and Taylor’s Brighton & Hove Odyssey by Spencer Vignes

Brian Howard Clough and Peter Thomas Taylor, more commonly known in the football world as simply, ‘Clough and Taylor’. Whatever your team, no one would begrudge their reputation as an outstanding management duo, who brought great success to football in the East Midlands, in the guise of Derby County and Nottingham Forest. And go into any bookshop and you will find a number of titles about their exploits at those two clubs. The major hole in their story is the time that the pair spent at then Third Division Brighton & Hove Albion, when they washed up on the shores of the South coast during the 1973/74 season after Pat Saward had lost his job as manager at the Goldstone Ground.

In Bloody Southerners – Clough and Taylor’s Brighton & Hove Odyssey, author Spencer Vignes produces an excellent account with interviews from players and staff at the clubs as well as local and national media of the time, to recount the story of the period that occurred between their stewardship at the Baseball Ground and the City Ground.

As with any good book, the central part of the story is detailed in context, with the reader presented with the early years of the pairs playing careers, their management time at Hartlepools United and later resignation from Derby County in October 1973. This provides the backdrop prior to Clough and Taylor taking the reins at Brighton in November 1973, brought in by ambitious Chairman Mike Bamber, the other main character in the book. There follows the story of Clough’s brief sojourn in the South, which was to last only until July 1974 when he jumped ship to take over at Elland Road, with Taylor staying and taking charge during the 1974/75 and 1975/76 campaigns.

Those seasons are well documented with in their first season, the infamous FA Cup replay defeat to Walton & Hersham detailed, as well as the 8-2 home defeat to a rampant Bristol Rovers. During that campaign, Clough does little to endear himself to the players, as he does not move down to Brighton (unlike Taylor), preferring instead to commute from Derby, meaning that his appearances on the training ground are limited. He also alienates the Club Chairman with his trip to discuss a possible job as Iranian National Manager, despite the flexibility Clough is given with regards to his media work. With his departure, Clough caused a rift with Taylor that whilst was to be resolved when they were reunited at Forest, started a fissure that was to return later in their careers and which because of the untimely death of Taylor, unfortunately was never to be resolved. Taylor himself also comes in for his share of criticism too once he became manager, with some not impressed at his time spent on the road looking for players, rather than being in the dug-out, especially in the critical run-in during the 1975/76 season when Brighton narrowly missed out on promotion.

Readers may conclude that it does not portray either Clough or Taylor in a particularly good light. However, whilst many of the interviews are critical of the pair, this book is by no means a hatchet job. Vignes builds a balanced case to show where some of the attitudes espoused by Clough came from, in areas such as his treatment of older and injured players and his relationship with Chairman. The author also succeeds in loosening some of the fictionalisation that has come to surround the pair with the making of The Damned United film, in sharpening the image of the reality of Clough and Taylor as men with faults, and not characters in soft-focus.

In closing the book, Vignes takes the Brighton story beyond the departure of Taylor and concludes with a chapter titled, An Unlikely Legacy, as the author lays out an interesting conclusion and reflection given the warts and all detail that had gone before. Bloody Southerners is a well-researched look at a period of the Clough and Taylor era that has been previously only seen as a footnote in their careers and is a must-read.

(Biteback Publishing. October 2018). Paperback 320pp)

 

Category: Reviews | LEAVE A COMMENT

Book Review: With Clough, By Taylor (with Mike Langley)

This book was originally published in October 1980 (cover right), and at that time the Clough and Taylor partnership was still going strong, with Nottingham Forest having collected a second European Cup triumph following a 1-0 win over a Hamburg side in Madrid containing Kevin Keegan. Within two years Peter Taylor resigned from Forest and took up the management of rivals Derby County from November 1982 to April 1984 and it was during this period that he and Brian Clough fell out, never to reconcile before Taylor’s death in October 1990 of pulmonary fibrosis while on holiday in Mallorca, at the age of just 62. This republishing of With Clough, By Taylor (cover below left) is sold with royalties donated to Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis (www.actionpulmonaryfibrosis.org)

Given this is a republishing almost forty-years later, the reader has the benefit of all the events post the original release in 1980 and therefore makes it a different read. For instance, back then any reader, given what the pair had achieved up to that point, might have comfortably assumed that there were more years of success to follow, whereas in fact within two years Clough and Taylor were no longer a partnership. And in some ways, it is interesting to see this reflected in the two covers from 1980 and the 2019 publications. The 80s version has the men together deep in concentration, focused on the action in front of them, whereas the latest edition sees them sat before the start of the 1980 European Cup Final, seemingly together but portraying a distance as well. It may simply be that they are nervous ahead of such a major game, or that they are uncomfortable with the intrusive nature of the photographers. However, given that the pair never reconciled after their row surrounding the John Robertson transfer, the current image may well have been chosen to reflect the split.

Of the content of the book itself, it follows a fairly chronological line of their time together and apart, starting with the initial meeting as players at Middlesbrough, where Taylor was a goalkeeper and Clough a centre-forward. It then documents their first managerial job at Hartlepools United, the triumph, trials and tribulations at Derby County, the time at Brighton & Hove Albion together and then with Taylor solely in charge and finally their tenure at Nottingham Forest. These parts of the book all feel fairly understated and it is not until Taylor comes onto other topics, in particular, Clough’s 44 days at Leeds United, Taylor’s views on the England team and the players in the game that he admired, that as a reader we get to see an animated  side of his character and get to read about Taylor’s undoubted understanding of players and their respective talents.

That Clough and Taylor were two different characters is reflected in the number of books about Clough, given the persona he portrayed to the world and his penchant for the outspoken and controversial, as the paucity of titles about Peter Taylor, who admitted himself, was uncomfortable in front of the media. The fact is that the pair were highly successful, and their different personalities and skills ensured that, as Clough acknowledged, “I’m not equipped to manage successfully without Peter Taylor. I am the shop window and he is the goods in the back.”

The ending of the book is on reflection a sad footnote, with Taylor stating, “Both of us are aware that it (our partnership) cannot last for ever and that we must part again one day. I hope we part on a high note and on the friendliest terms, and that football will remember us as pioneers of management – the first to see that two heads are better than one.” Clough and Taylor will always be remembered as a unique and successful partnership and indeed will always be part of football history and folklore, the pity though is that their friendship never had that chance of a final reconciliation.

(Biteback Publishing, 24 Jan. 2019. Paperback 288pp)

 

Category: Reviews | LEAVE A COMMENT